Two Quotes, the Same Teeth, and a $3,000 Gap

Collect three orthodontic quotes in the Bay Area, and you will get three different numbers. Sometimes they sit a few hundred dollars apart. Sometimes the gap is three thousand. Patients bring us competing treatment plans constantly and ask the only reasonable question: Is one of these people wrong?


Usually not. Usually they are quoting different things, and the paperwork does a poor job of showing you that.


Start with who is holding the pliers. A general dentist can legally offer aligners. An orthodontist has spent two to three additional years in residency after dental school working on nothing but tooth movement, jaw growth, and bite mechanics. That training shows up in the fee. It also shows up in the cases that get referred to us after they stall somewhere else, which is a meaningful share of what we see. Every doctor at OrthoWorks is an orthodontic specialist with that residency training behind them. There is no general dentist here doing orthodontics on the side.


Then find out what the number actually covers. This is where most of the gap hides, and it is worth being slightly annoying about. Ask what happens when a bracket breaks. Ask whether retainers are included or billed separately at the end, because the end is a favorite place to park a few hundred dollars. Ask how many aligner refinements are covered when teeth do not track the way the software predicted, because some do not, and refinements are where an inexpensive plan quietly becomes an expensive one. Ask what happens to the fee if treatment runs six months past the estimate.


A quote that covers 18 months and a quote that covers the case however long it takes are not comparable, even when the two numbers look close on paper.


Then ask whether it has to be one decision. Most quotes hand you the full result as a single number, take it or leave it. Aligner treatment does not have to work that way, because in many cases it can be taken in stages, with a shorter first course now and the rest quoted on its own when you are ready. A practice that never raises this is showing you one option and calling it the price. We have written about how staging works in a separate article, linked below.


Then ask how much planning is behind it. Aligner treatment mapped in 20 minutes and aligner treatment mapped from a full diagnostic workup are both sold to you as the same thing. At OrthoWorks, planning starts with a 3D digital scan, and when clinically indicated, treatment planning may also incorporate cone beam imaging and a specialist’s assessment of the airway and the jaw joint. Not every case calls for every one of those. One of those two plans is considerably more likely to finish on schedule, and finishing on schedule is itself a cost.


We have been at this a while, and two things are true at once. OrthoWorks was founded in 1920 by William Sylvester Smith and has operated continuously in the Bay Area ever since, which makes it the longest-running privately owned orthodontic practice in the region. Separately, the orthodontists practicing here today carry more than 100 years of combined clinical experience between them. Those are two different facts and we try not to blur them.


The practice is led today by Dr. David Shen, who has spent more than 40 years in the exclusive practice of orthodontics. Under his leadership, the practice has grown from three locations to eight, served 80,000+ patients, and completed more than 10,000 Invisalign cases.


None of that guarantees we are the lowest quote in your stack. What it does mean is that when your case turns out to be more complicated than it looked in the first photograph, nobody here is learning on you.


And to be fair about it: a lower quote is not automatically a worse one. Some cases genuinely are simple, and a simple case should be priced like a simple case. Our own range starts at $3,295 for exactly that reason. The point is not to assume expensive means better. The point is to make sure you are comparing the same job.


So bring us the other quote. Second opinions are free here; they include a full specialist exam and a digital scan, and you are under no obligation to switch. If the plan you were handed is sound and fairly priced, we will tell you so, and you can walk out and take it. If something is missing from it, you will know exactly what and exactly why before you sign anything.


Book a free second opinion at any of our eight Bay Area offices. Worst case, you leave with confidence in the decision you were already making.


Related Readings